Crop hub · Garden · Home garden

Milkweed

Monarchs come first. If you grow milkweed for butterflies, do not spray it with insecticides. In University of Florida trials, imidacloprid, acetamiprid and flupyradifurone killed every monarch caterpillar fed on treated plants the day after application, and imidacloprid and flupyradifurone still killed most at two weeks. Another systemic, pymetrozine, was still killing caterpillars four weeks on, twice as long as it held the aphids down. Insecticidal soap did not kill caterpillars directly, but it never brought the aphids below the treatment threshold. UF/IFAS discourages pesticides on milkweed and says to expect some cosmetic damage through the season. Check for monarch eggs and small caterpillars before you squash, prune or hose anything.

The crowds of bright yellow, black-legged aphids on the shoot tips and flowers are oleander aphid. The damage is mostly honeydew and sooty mould, but it costs monarchs indirectly: in a Florida study, females laid three times as many eggs on aphid-free plants. UF/IFAS advises a blast of water from the hose instead of pesticides. Squash colonies or prune the worst tips, and let the hoverflies and parasitic wasps that follow them build up.

The orange-and-black bugs on the pods are milkweed bugs. The large milkweed bug, ½–1 inch long, feeds on the seeds, leaves and stems, and Missouri's field guide says it does not damage milkweed much unless numbers are exceptional. The small milkweed bug, about ½ inch with a red-orange X on its back, sips nectar and sap from milkweed seeds and also scavenges. Both store milkweed toxins, as monarchs do, and their black-and-orange colours warn predators off. Leave them alone. The caterpillars stripping the leaves may be the monarchs you planted it for: UF/IFAS says they can eat a plant's leaves quickly but do not usually damage it long-term.

crop context · milkweed pods with yellow aphids

The one pest worth acting on, gently

JULY–OCTOBER · ALL YEAR IN FLORIDA

Oleander aphid

Dense yellow colonies on shoot tips and flowers; honeydew and sooty mould, and fewer monarch eggs on infested plants.

ReleaseHoverfliesWild — plant a mix of flowers near the milkweed

Season calendar

US GARDENS · QUALITATIVE · YEAR-ROUND IN FLORIDA
JFMAMJJASOND
Oleander aphidJan: BuildingFeb: BuildingMar: BuildingApr: BuildingMay: BuildingJun: BuildingJul: Pest pressure highAug: Pest pressure highSep: Pest pressure highOct: Pest pressure highNov: BuildingDec: Building

Starter program

Nothing on milkweed should be bought and released, and nothing should be sprayed. This is the order of jobs for a monarch garden.

  1. BEFORE ANYTHINGLook for monarch eggs and caterpillarsCheck stems and leaf undersides before you squash, prune or hose
  2. FIRST COLONIESHose or squash the aphidsA blast of water from the hose, not a pesticide
  3. HEAVY COLONIESPrune the worst tipsCut out the most crowded shoots
  4. ALL SEASONHoverfliesPlant a mix of flowers nearby; more flower variety in milkweed gardens has meant more predatory insects
  5. ALL SEASONBraconid waspsPapery, light-brown swollen aphids are parasitised; leave them for the next generation of wasps

Setting up the garden

In a pollinator garden, most of the setup is about what you leave out.

No systemic insecticides

In University of Florida trials, imidacloprid, acetamiprid and flupyradifurone killed monarch caterpillars on treated plants, and pymetrozine was still killing them four weeks after treatment.

Soap is safe but weak

The same trials found insecticidal soap did not kill monarch caterpillars directly, but it never held oleander aphid below the treatment threshold. Water and fingers do as much.

Ask how nursery plants were grown

Before buying milkweed, ask whether it was treated with a systemic insecticide in the nursery; the Florida trials found treated plants can harm caterpillars for weeks.

Skip tropical milkweed in Florida

UF/IFAS treats tropical milkweed as invasive in Florida and does not recommend planting it.