Wild beneficial

Praying mantis

Tenodera sinensis, Mantis religiosa and Stagmomantis carolina
The short answer

Mantises are ambush predators that eat any insect they can catch, which makes them poor pest control. UC IPM says they are of no benefit for biological pest control, because they take bees, butterflies and hoverflies as readily as pests. Three species are common in Kentucky and the upper Midwest, and only the small Carolina mantis is native. The large Chinese mantis and the European mantis were introduced. The egg cases sold online are Chinese mantis cases, and ARBICO says its cases are collected in the wild. Enjoy the mantises you find, but don't buy them to control a pest.

Controls these pests
Spotted lanternflyMOST-REPORTED BUG PREDATORBrown marmorated stink bugOBSERVED PREDATOR
Grasshoppers, crickets, moths, fliesPREY
Bees, butterflies, hoverfliesALSO PREY — THE PROBLEM
hero macro · Chinese mantis on a stem; a tan, foamy egg case on a twig

At a glance

Kind
Wild — ARBICO's egg cases are wild-collected, not reared
Chinese mantis
Up to 5 in (13 cm); introduced 1896
European mantis
About 3 in; black spot under the foreleg
Carolina mantis
About 2–2½ in; the native one
Egg case
12 to 400 eggs; hatches in spring
Generations
One a year; adults die of old age or freezing

How it works

A mantis waits motionless on a stem, camouflaged, and swivels its head to track prey. It strikes with front legs lined with sharp spines, which pin the prey while it is eaten. Nymphs start hunting as soon as they hatch, and their first meal is often a sibling. They grow through the summer and take larger prey as they go. Adults mate in late summer, and the female sometimes eats the male. She lays her eggs and dies when it freezes. There is one generation a year.

The egg case, or ootheca, starts as a frothy mass that hardens into a crusty, Styrofoam-like shell on a twig, stem or other surface. It holds anywhere from a dozen to 400 eggs, depending on the species. A Chinese mantis case is tan, about as long as it is wide, and the size of a ping-pong ball, like a toasted marshmallow on a twig. The eggs overwinter, and the nymphs come out in spring almost all at once. A case brought indoors will hatch in the house in winter. Iowa State advises keeping a collected case in a box or jar in an unheated garage or porch, and watching for the hatch from about mid-May. If the nymphs cannot scatter within a day or two, they eat each other.

The native Carolina mantis (Stagmomantis carolina) is the smallest; the adult female's wings reach only three-quarters of the way down her abdomen. The European mantis (Mantis religiosa) is tan to bright green and has a round black spot, sometimes white-centred, under the base of each foreleg. The Chinese mantis (Tenodera sinensis) is the largest, pale green to tan, with a green line along the edge of the forewings. The Missouri Department of Conservation suggests that the introduced species may be outcompeting native mantids. It suggests selectively destroying Chinese and European mantids and their egg cases, and leaving the native Carolina alone. It also notes that large Chinese mantis females have occasionally been recorded eating small reptiles, amphibians and even hummingbirds.

What it is confused with

Only one of the three common mantises is native. Their egg cases are also easy to confuse with the egg masses of two pests, which you should destroy.

  1. Also goodCarolina mantis — The native species. It is smaller, about 2–2½ inches, pale green to tan or mottled grey. The adult female's wings stop three-quarters of the way down her abdomen. Leave it and its egg cases alone.
  2. PestSpongy moth egg mass — Tan and fuzzy rather than hard and foamy, about 1½ by ¾ inches, laid flat on trunks, stones, walls and outdoor furniture. It holds up to 1,000 eggs. Scrape it into soapy water. See spongy moth.
  3. PestSpotted lanternfly egg mass — Flat rows of eggs about an inch long, under a coating that turns from creamy white to pinkish grey, then tan and cracked. It is laid on bark, stone and vehicles. A mantis case is a raised, rounded foam. Scrape it off; see spotted lanternfly.

How to keep it around

You cannot attract mantises to one particular pest, but you can keep the ones you have. Kentucky Extension's advice is to limit pesticide use and let some vegetation grow for cover.

What drives it off

Pesticide sensitivity

Kentucky Extension says some insecticides can drastically reduce mantid numbers. Bt and insecticidal soap have little impact on mantids compared with broad-spectrum insecticides. Open the compatibility matrix →

When to choose something else

Mantises eat pests, but not selectively enough, or in the numbers needed, to control one. Look elsewhere when:

  • Aphids are the problem — lady beetle larvae, hoverfly larvae and green lacewings go to the colony; Kentucky Extension rates mantids' value as small next to lady beetles and lacewings
  • Caterpillars are eating the crop — Bt kurstaki targets them and spares mantids
  • Spotted lanternflies are the target — mantises eat them, but Penn State says more research is needed to show they reduce numbers; scrape egg masses (spotted lanternfly)
  • You want to protect pollinators — a mantis waiting on a flower is hunting bees, butterflies and hoverflies
  • You are thinking of seeding the garden with egg cases — Kentucky Extension notes that more cases may not mean more mantids, because the nymphs move away to find cover and food, and UW–Madison adds that cannibalism limits their numbers

Where to buy

Where to buy praying mantis egg cases: the honest answer is that they are a poor use of money, and in 2026 they are also hard to get. The cases on sale are the introduced Chinese mantis, though ARBICO says a few Carolina cases may be mixed in. This is what three US suppliers showed on 23 September 2026:

  • ARBICO OrganicsWild-collected cases, 50–200 eggs each — not shipping in 2026, citing APHIS restrictionsUS
  • Buglogical2 / 4 / 8 cases at $18.95 / $34.95 / $54.95, ~200 nymphs each — out of stockUS
  • Planet NaturalCases of 50–200 nymphs; 3 suggested for under 5,000 sq ft — no price shownUS

Praying mantis by target

What it eats and when it turns up differ by pest. Each page below is the picture for one target.